Cindy Gayle

Associate Real Estate Broker

Photo of Cindy Gayle

Cindy Gayle
Associate Real Estate Broker

At a glance

My Communities
Armonk, Bedford, Chappaqua, Cross River, Dobbs Ferry, Goldens Bridge, Greenburgh, Hartsdale, Irvington, Katonah, Lewisboro, Mahopac, Mount Kisco, Mount Pleasant, Pleasantville, Pound Ridge, Sleepy Hollow, Somers, South Salem, Tarrytown, Thornwood, Valhalla, Waccabuc, White Plains

Listing Specialist, Expert Negotiator, Staging Properties, First time home buyers, Investment Properties

21 Years

Properties Sold

About me

Cindy Gayle, CBR, CRS, SRES As a lifelong resident of Westchester County, I am a dedicated real estate broker who puts my heart and soul into doing what I love most.  Selling, buying and investing in real estate. I have received numerous awards for my accomplishments from the Hudson Gateway Association of Realtors as well as companies I've been associated with.  I deliver superior customer service, knowledge of both current and changing real estate markets. Encouraged at a very early age by my father, real estate Broker/Owner and land developer.  I believe my desire and interest in real estate is somewhat generic, in which for many years now has lead me to a very successful career. I have watch the topography of much of Westchester's land evolve into many different forms.  Farmland to developments, gated communities, restored cottages, mansions along the Hudson and of course multi-million dollar residences everywhere. My broad clientele... More

Professional Associations & Designations

I have been designated as a CRS - Certified Relocation Specialist, CBR - Certified Buyers Representative, and SRES - Senior Real Estate Specialist, and Associate Real Estate broker.  I am a Luxury Homes Specialist.  

I am a member of the National Association of Realtors, the New York State Association of Realtors, Hudson Gateway Association of Realtors, and the Hudson Gateway Multiple Listing Service.


Cindy was extremely knowledgeable in the real estate market and provided invaluable advice as to the sale of our home. Truly a professional in every respect and I would highly recommend Cindy in any or all real estate transactions. It has truly been a pleasure working with Cindy in our successful sale of our home! Mary Casterella

Cindy is very professional, knowledgeable, a good negotiator, and follows-up. She sold my home in less than a week. We followed her instructions and had a full ask offer no back and forth with buyer. Smooth sailing during the entire transaction. Her extensive real estate knowledge and integrity makes her a valuable asset to her clients. MariaC

Cindy is a top notch professional who has a mastery of her market. Cindy really spent the time understanding what we were looking for and our criteria. She even previewed homes for us because she knew we were busy and would call and provide guidance on whether to take the time to go view. Often times Cindy would call me and say
“you’re not going to like this one and here’s why”. She is not in for the quick
sale and to move you along. Cindy understands buying a new home is a big
decision and what really sets Cindy apart from her peers is her patience and
kindness. She is never frustrated and is a great person who is truly competent
and honest in providing you guidance and advice. Truly the best realtor I’ve
worked with
. Rita

Cindy Gayle is a terrific real estate agent! She went above and beyond for our family, researching and showing us listings, providing valuable information on our target neighborhoods and negotiating effectively and fairly. She was there for us every step of the way and answered all of our questions promptly. She let us know from the beginning that she was serious and she meant it. Cindy guided us every step of the way. We've been in our new home 3 months now and couldn't be happier with how everything turned out. Brian Harrison

Cindy has been extremely helpful in our search for a family home around Armonk and Briarcliff. She gave freely of her time and expertise, and her dedication shone through. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend Cindy to other potential buyers. Thank you Cindy! MSherrell

I contacted Cindy when we needed to sell my mother's home when she moved to an assisted living facility. Cindy was wonderful. The house was priced realistically and sold quickly. Cindy was there for us every step of the way, right through closing. She was always available to take my calls or returned calls promptly. She was available to answer questions or just calm my nerves when the process seemed overwhelming. I am happy to have the opportunity to give Cindy the highest recommendation. Cathy O’Neil

Cindy was extremely helpful and resourceful in getting my house sold she was quick to respond to any questions and wise in helping me through the negotiating process with the buyer She was a delight to work with. We couldn’t have been a better experience. Dr. Albert Brok

Cindy was very well prepared and knowledgeable about our condo and its location. She suggested we set it a reasonable price. We even received a full price offer! But, as things happen in real estate that did not come true. Undeterred, and with the same energy, Cindy set about finding a new buyer. When issues arose during inspection, Cindy made the process of repairing them as easy as possible. She was always on our side and made sure we received the best possible offer. If we move back to the area, we will definitely have her as our agent.
Mark Pagliaro

Cindy is an exceptional Real Estate Lady to work with. Cindy is extremely Knowledgeable and Caring and looks out for your interests. Always answered my questions and kept me informed. Would highly recommend using Cindy Gayle for buying or selling your home. Peggy Wiand

We recently worked with Cindy when we began our search for our "forever house". She was very patient and honest while looking at all the different homes. When we finally found "the one" she was super responsive (taking calls on vacation) during the negotiation process and professional during every step of our home buying experience. I would recommend Cindy to anyone buying or selling a home because you will feel like she is your friend, not an agent, and you will feel that security that she is always working for you. MaryJane Volkson

My wife and I recently moved from Denmark - an experience that would have been extremely stressful had it not been for Cindy Gayle. From the moment we spoke to her about our housing needs, she was attentive, sensitive, actually 'listened' and guided us and helped us every step of the way.-- I cannot recommend her qualities of professionalism and her manner of courtesy and kindness highly enough - she is simply 'the best', Richard and Joan Bowell

“Cindy places customer service above all else." She has a profound knowledge of the current, as well as, changing real estate markets. Her honesty shows forth in all her business transactions. In summary, Cindy is a dedicated real estate broker who puts her heart and soul into doing what she loves - helping others sell, buy, and invest in real estate.” Thomas Marino

Top qualities: Personable, On Time, High Integrity   “Cindy was extremely competent while being totally personable at the same time. I could rely on her and felt I was in good hands when I was considering buying a house. I would use her again without hesitation and recommend her highly for anyone looking to buy or sell a house in Westchester, New York. It is a pleasure to work with someone with the integrity and grace that Cindy carries herself with. Jeanette Sandor

Dear Cindy, My family and I will be raising a glass and toasting you this Thanksgiving. Your marketing and negotiating skills sold my house.  I never felt pressured when you offered your suggestions and guidance.  You are a professional who knows the ever changing real estate market. Thank you.
Sincerely, Irene G. Petrillo­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­

Cindy is a delightful individual. She was able to provide us with pointers in order to get the most value from our house. This is an old home and needed a lifetime of articles removed. Cindy advised on what to keep in the home and what items to remove. Cindy was prompt in providing feedback. I would recommend Cindy to anyone who wishes to sell their home. Dennis Gilhooly


I was new to the area (Pound Ridge) and also my first home purchase in the US To say that Cindy was fantastic is a complete understatement She continuously went the extra mile on my behalf at every turn - she negotiated on price, went to the local Town Hall for background info on the property, helped with Codes, issues on inspections, etc., name it, Cindy either did it or fully supported us in the process... She was fantastic from start to finish Nothing was too much for her - even negotiating offers on my behalf at 9/10pm on a Saturday evening - way above anything that could be expected I have worked and lived across several countries, have purchased and rented property in these countries; I have never met someone with such drive, energy and enthusiasm for the role Cindy performs It is clear Cindy enjoys what she is doing and this enjoyment is clearly demonstrated in the level of service given to her clients Needless to say I would fully endorse Cindy to any of my friends, relatives or colleagues looking for the services of a Realtor in the future!
Paul Cowan


Cindy is the consummate professional. By that I mean she really knows the real estate business, and proves it by getting results. I have listed two relatively unique rental properties with Cindy over the past 5 years. In both cases she found the perfect people. I could not be happier.   

Dr. Paul J Krick

Cindy, Just a note of thanks for all your help in buying our new home and selling our former.  You knew and understood our needs and requirements for a new residence and worked tirelessly to find us the right property. Thanks to your help and guidance we are now happy and comfortable in our new home.   On the sale of the our former home, once we put it in your very capable hands the sale happened quickly with no stress and little effort on our part. That was much appreciated since we had multiple other issues going on at the time.   You are a true professional and friend. Sincere gratitude'   Phyllis and Doug Cassetta 

My experience with Cindy Gayle far exceeded my expectations. She was with me, and in my corner, on every detail from start to finish. Her knowledge and dedication were exemplary which made for a very comfortable experience. I highly recommend Cindy. James Porteus

When we called Coldwell Banker to find a real estate broker to help us sell our home the phone at Coldwell Banker was answered by Cindy Gayle. It started at "Hello" Cindy was cordial, knowledgeable and very friendly. At her first visit to us we knew immediately she was the right broker. She showed patience and gave us the right guidance. Cindy's presentation of our home was beyond professionally done, the lighting, the staging and the personal touches captured our home at its most beautiful. We sold our home in 4 months. Whether it was luck or fate, we would strongly recommend her to family and friends. She is first rate, knows the marketplace and a "good soul."

Gerry & Bernadette Barandes


Cindy is very skilled at what she does and goes above and beyond to get things done right and timely. She was always willing to answer any questions and set me up with the right people I needed to sell my home and purchase a new one. Cindy is a go getter as well as very personable and kind.  Noelle Harrison

- December 6, 2019